5 Big Mistakes Companies Make When Tackling ESG

Curated by WorkingFromHome

This article is an excerpt from the original article found in the Read More link – please follow for full article.

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

You’re reading Entrepreneur United States, an international franchise of Entrepreneur Media.

From corporate boardrooms to social media, ESG is the matter of the moment. Those who have been around the corporate management block will remember how “sustainability” has shifted from the Triple Bottom Line to Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), and now, in its latest iteration, as Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG). Companies across various industries are pursuing sustainability by developing and implementing ESG strategies.

But as the fervor of environmental, social and governance reporting builds, meaningful performance metrics lag.

Despite ESG’s rising prominence on corporate and investor agendas, a high level of confusion continues to surround standard requirements, climate risk and climate opportunity. Based on my experience working with companies large and small on a wide range of strategic issues, companies tend to make the following key mistakes when tacking ESG.

1. Avoiding the issue 

It is a fallacy to think that ESG is a passing phenomenon. Rather than a disparate fad, ESG is the next iteration of a common thread — sustainability. Sustainability in the early ’90s and ’00s invited the corporate world to consider social and environmental factors in line with the traditional financial bottom line. In practice, the triple bottom line placed an outsized focus on environmental performance, risk management and efficiency orientation. Applied to company strategy, the triple bottom line was loosely defined and often lacked a systematic, actionable approach to KPIs. 

The triple bottom line came to represent the principal theme of corporate social responsibility (CSR). Stakeholder capitalism taking ground, CSR mostly focused on discrete initiatives, such as corporate engagement with non-profits and stakeholder engagement, alongside other philanthropic efforts. Focused on a company’s accountability to stakeholders and the public, as well as its license to operate, CSR was an orientation in holistic reputation management. Tending to focus on program activities and their output, as with the triple bottom line, CSR too often lacks meaningful KPIs. 

From this perspective, ESG is the next edition of this development. What’s changed? Instead of being internally led by corporations, investors have begun to drive the conversation by requiring ESG performance metrics as a precursor to investment. ESG concentrates on the entire range of non-financial issues that impact a company’s performance, its impact on society and the effect it has on the environment. Widening to include governance as a parameter, ESG places focus on the separation of power and duties, how decisions are made in organizations and other ethical considerations in doing business. Governance is sometimes used as a way to gauge leadership’s level of maturity, in terms of just good management. Now, there’s a real desire not just to measure but also manage all of these factors. And this is not going to let up.

This version of corporate sustainability introduced risk management and value creation. With a greater focus on KPIs, ESG gave fundamental importance to the measurement, monitoring and reporting of a company’s sustainability performance. Several voluntary reporting frameworks currently conceptualize ESG. A source of confusion and frustration, these are slowly moving towards harmonization. Investment professionals now are willing to pay a median premium of 10% for companies with a strong track record on ESG over those without it. Companies that voluntarily report their carbon emissions can save on average $1.5 million every year in interest repayments because of the lower cost of capital.

Related: MFIs and ESG Framework: Fostering a Foundation For Sustainable Development

2. Overwhelm and grasp at the straws 

In the wild west of ESG, this reaction is completely understandable. An alphabet soup of frameworks, standards and guidelines — UNPRI, SASB, PRI, SBTi, CDP, TCFD, SDGs, MSCI, GRI to name a few — can be overwhelming. The sense of urgency is heightened by the accepted belief that similar to financial reporting, one dominant standard must also emerge for ESG reporting. For companies, this can be very difficult to navigate. 

As regulatory action on sustainability reporting seems imminent, pressure mounts on companies, standards and investors to subscribe to a consistent singular framework. This can be seen in the recent G7 meeting looking to require TCFD disclosures or the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) considering the implementation of ESG reporting regulations.

The lack of a common framework to compare the ESG reporting performance of different companies is a critical concern for transparency. Inconsistencies in the guidance and prescriptive actions given to companies mean “ESG” varies significantly on a practical level: the performance data that is being collected, presented and used to inform company strategy. It does not help that over half of the largest asset managers have been developing their own ESG frameworks. Nevertheless, the need for rigorous and quantitative company performance data continues to escalate in response to increasing pressure from investors, consumers and governments.  

The knee-jerk response of companies is to frantically respond to every request from reporting entities or simply freeze and do nothing. As a result, time and effort are expended quelling near-constant fires, while the smoke obscures any connection to the overall company strategy and direction. In this setting, organizational silos proliferate.  

This has a lasting impact on employee morale and consumer trust. By increasingly valuing company sustainability and ESG, these groups find themselves whiplashed by erratic corporate efforts of which they become increasingly mistrustful. 

The reality on the ground is that a lot of ESG issues are hard to define and measure in a meaningful way, particularly the social elements. Different industries have different levels of risk and different expectations of them. The scope of issues is still being defined.

Therefore companies must own their ESG narrative, which begins with conducting a materiality assessment to develop a deep understanding of what issues are relevant to the company’s core mission and strategy, and what matters to its customers, employees, investors and other stakeholders. As with many things, constructing an understanding of these issues from the very beginning and then building internal programs and directing efforts on that basis will have huge savings on time, money and effort down the line.

3. A bolted-on approach 

Companies that treat ESG as something extraneous to their organization face apathy, a perennial lack of resources and confusion in the face of ever-escalating stakeholder and regulator expectations. ESG is an operating philosophy and must be integrated with the overall company strategy. 

There is an increasing expectation to manage and show progress on ESG issues. Accompanying these growing expectations is increasing concern about greenwashing. ESG is only as good as a company makes it. For those who are interested in taking ESG seriously, actions that “walk the walk” are likely to include expending time and energy collecting rigorous performance data based on the results of an internal materiality assessment. Or, it might include ensuring data integrity, setting ESG-related metrics and KPIs and tying executive compensation to the achievement of those results. Use the systems you have to further a well-thought-out, fully integrated ESG strategy by connecting them to company-wide goals, metrics and priorities. Integrate your existing risk management system, your supply chain management function and your vendor selection tools and procedures.

Related: ESG, SRI and Impact Investing: What’s the Difference and What’s Best for Your Portfolio?

4. Thoughtless marketing

Over the last year, company interest in ESG credentialism has skyrocketed. Any self-respecting company is now expected to have a climate, sustainability as well as a diversity and inclusion statement, while many others have begun following suit. However, the lack of concrete action and the prevalence of chitter-chatter is seeing growing pushback. 

Sustainability statements are rife, identical, and often unsubstantiated — unsupported by corporate strategy and action. The trend towards greenwashing is a wasted effort for companies facing growing skepticism from customers and governments who are starting to demand sincerity.

5. Taking it too far 

Optimizing ESG is a balancing act and leaning too heavily on one parameter will compromise the outcome. Just as a world built on a single financial bottom-line has resulted in social and environmental neglect, economic prosperity cannot be forgotten in the gold rush on ESG.

The bottom line is that ESG performance is not just a measure of the company’s commitment and performance in their communities. It is increasingly seen as a proxy for not just for caring about others, but plain good management.

Related: 5 Big (and Common) Mistakes ESG Investors Make — Are You Making Them?

Source: Entrepreneur.com

Read the original here:
5 Big Mistakes Companies Make When Tackling ESG

You May Also Like…

Capital One vs. Ally: Which Credit Services Stock is a Better Buy?

Capital One vs. Ally: Which Credit Services Stock is a Better Buy?

The credit services industry has been making an impressive comeback on rising credit transactions and consumers’ increased discretionary spending. So, Capital One Financial (COF) and Ally (ALLY) should benefit from the industry tailwinds. But which of these two stocks is a better buy now? Read more to learn our view. shutterstock.com – StockNews Capital One Financial Corporation (COF) in McLean, Va., is a diversified financial service holding company that offers a range of financial products and services to consumers, small businesses, and commercial clients through branches, the internet, and other distribution channels. It operates through three segments: Credit Card, Consumer Banking, and Commercial Banking. In comparison, Ally Financial Inc. (ALLY) in Detroit, Mich., is a bank holding company that provides various digital financial products and services to consumer, commercial, and corporate customers. It operates through Automotive Finance Operations, Insurance Operations, Mortgage Finance Operations, and Corporate Finance Operations segments.The credit services…

It’s Time to Step into Yum! Brands Stock

It’s Time to Step into Yum! Brands Stock

Popular restaurant franchisor Yum! Brands (NYSE: YUM) stock has been selling off with the benchmark indexes despite strong earnings. The Company is a franchisor of well-known restaurant brands including KFC, Pizza Hut, Taco Bell, and Habit Burger Grill. All brands are growing with KFC leading the pack at an 11% clip. The price/earnings is falling back to earth at 27X forward earnings. The Company has over 50,000 locations and launched 760 new restaurants in Q3 2021 with plans to continue opening new units at a 4.5% rate. The Company was a pandemic winner thanks to its drive-ins, mobile ordering, and take-out options. It continues to thrive during the reopening phase and even through COVID omicron surges as its touchless options are paying off. The recent selling in shares if providing prudent investors with opportunistic pullback levels to consider building a position in this value stock. Depositphotos.com contributor/Depositphotos.com – MarketBeat Q3…

Working From Home TV …

Tips to enhance your own website…

How to Create a Giveaway to Grow Your Email List by 150% – Website Tips

How to Create a Giveaway to Grow Your Email List by 150% – Website Tips

Do you want to start a giveaway and get more email subscribers? Giveaways are one of the fastest ways to grow your email list, increase traffic, and boost sales. They help you reach new audiences and boost user engagement on your website. In this article, we’ll show you how to use a giveaway to grow your email list faster. Why Use a Giveaway to Grow Your Email List? Did you know that email marketing sees a 4300% return on investment (ROI) on average for businesses in the US? People who sign up for your emails are already interested in your products and services, making them highly likely to convert into paying customers. However, the hardest part is getting more people to join your email list. This is where running a contest or giveaway on your WordPress site comes in handy. It helps you grow your email list while getting more…

How to Track Video Analytics in WordPress (Step by Step) – Website Tips

How to Track Video Analytics in WordPress (Step by Step) – Website Tips

Do you want to know which videos your visitors watch the most on your WordPress website? Videos are a great way to bring life to your website and boost engagement. By tracking video analytics, you can see how your videos are performing with metrics like total views, watch duration, and more. In this article, we’ll show you how to track video analytics in WordPress using Google Analytics. This solution works for YouTube, Vimeo, and other HTML5 video embeds. Why Track Video Engagement in WordPress? Adding videos to your content makes your articles more engaging and helps in getting people to spend more time on your site. However, if you have multiple videos on your WordPress site, then how do you which type of content is performing the best and whether people are watching your videos or not? Tracking video engagement in Google Analytics can help you uncover these insights. You…

How to Easily Create a Custom WordPress Theme (Without Any Code) – Website Tips

How to Easily Create a Custom WordPress Theme (Without Any Code) – Website Tips

Do you want to create a custom WordPress theme from scratch? In the past, you had to follow complicated WordPress tutorials and have decent coding knowledge to build a custom WordPress theme. But thanks to new WordPress theme builders, now you can easily make one without learning any programming skills. In this article, we’ll show you how to easily create a custom WordPress theme without writing any code. Here is the list of topics we’ll cover in this article. Creating a Custom WordPress Theme for BeginnersCreating a Custom Theme with SeedProd Theme BuilderEditing a Theme with SeedProd Theme BuilderChanging the Site-Wide Design for Your ThemeApplying and Publishing Your Custom WordPress ThemeCreating Other Layouts for Your Custom WordPress ThemeReady? Let’s get started. Video Tutorial Subscribe to WPBeginner If you’d prefer written instructions, just keep reading. Creating a Custom WordPress Theme for Beginners A WordPress website uses a theme for website layout…


Submit a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.